Vultures of Kerala-38

De facto `cWIÀ¯m¡Ä...

De facto; De jure F¶ {]tbmK§Ä e¯o³ `mjbn \ne\nev¡p¶p. De facto F¶ph¨m “bYmÀ°¯nÂ, hmkvXh¯n” Fs¶ms¡ aebmf¯n ]cn`mjs¸Sp¯mw. De jure F¶m “\nbaZrãym, \nbam\pkcWw” Fs¶ms¡bmWÀ°w. A[nImcsaÃmw De jure A[nImcn¡msW¦nepw iànbpw IgnhpsaÃmw ‘De facto’ A[nImcnIÄ (?)¡mbncn¡pw. Hcp kn\nabnse UbtemKv ISsaSp¯mÂ, (Hcp s]meokpImc³ At±l¯nsâ taeptZymKØt\mSv ]dbp¶XmWv ]Ým¯ew) “kÀ, \manSp¶ Cu bqWnt^mdw kÀ¡mcn\v th­nbn«msW¦nepw AXv \ap¡v hm§n ssX¸n¨v Xcp¶Xv \½psS A_vImcn apXemfn... kmÀ BWv.” F¶v h¨m Xm¦fpsS De jure A[nImc¯n\v A_vImcnbpsS De facto A[nImc¯n\p ap¼n H¶pw sN¿m\mhnsöÀ°w. B s]meokpImc³ ]dªXv AhKWn¨v {]hÀ¯n¨ B “De jure” A[nImcn A[nIw XmaknbmsX “AIs¸«p”t]mbnsb¶XmWv A\´c cwK§Ä ImWn¡p¶Xv. `cWIqSt¯bpw AhcpsS ]mÀ«ntbbpw Xm§n\nÀ¯p¶ De facto A_vImcn apXemfnamÀ¡v \nbahpw \oXnbpw s]meokpw \nba]pkvXIhpw tImSXnIfpw {]iv\aÃmbncn¡mw. ImcWw De jure A[nImcnIfÃtÃm cmPyw `cn¡p¶Xv. CsXmcp P\m[n]Xy `cWatÃ?

“IqsS¡qSm\pw sh«ns¡mÃm\pw BfpIfps­¦n Bsc t]Sn¡Ww?” A¯cw kµÀ`§fn De jure A[nImcnIÄ AhcpsS hmÄ Ddbnen«§s\ FÃmw I­ncn¡p¶ ImgvNbmWv \mw I­p hcp¶Xv. De facto A[nImcnIÄ ]dªm tIÄ¡m\mfp­vþ XÃm\pw XÃns¡mÃm\pwhsc BfpIÄ. sh«n\nc¯m\pw sh«n¸nSn¡m\pw hsc BfpIÄ. apãnNpcp«m\pw aq¡pIbdn«p ]nSn¨v ap{ZmhmIyw hnfn¡m\pw hsc BÄ¡mÀ. A¯c¯nepÅ De facto A[nImcnIsf cmjv{Sob¯nepw aXþhÀ¤ob kwLS\Ifnepw sXmgn taJebnepw hnZymÀ°n {]Øm\¯nepsaÃmw [mcmfw ImWmw. ]eX«pIfn {]hÀ¯n¡p¶ C¡q«À¡v cmjv{Sob taemf·mcpsS klIcWhpw kt¸mÀ«pw In«p¶Xn\m AhcpsS ap¼n De jure A[nImcnIfpsS Iogn {]hÀ¯n¡p¶ DtZymKØcpw Ahcn ]ecptSbpw apIfn Ccn¡p¶ taeptZym KØcpw Nnet¸mÄ ]dª De jure ¡mcpsS \nb{´W¯n\v hnt[bcmbn tPmen sN¿p¶hcmbncn¡pw. Cu “hnt[b·mÀ” hnizkvXXtbmsS sN¿p¶Xns\Ãmw At¸mÄ De facto BioÀhmZhpw De jure B[nImcnIXbpw Ds­¶ncn¡pw. tImSXnIÄ hsc Nnet¸mÄ De facto A[nImcnIfpsS XWenemWv {]hÀ¯n¡p¶sX¶ Bt£]hpw tIÄ¡mw. tIÄ¡p¶sXÃmw icnbmItà F¶m{Kln¡pI am{XamWv km[mcW¡mcpsS {]mÀ°\.

De jurebpw De factobpw kt½fn¨m AsXmcp h³iànXs¶ Bbncn¡pw. NnecXns\ Ahnip² Iq«psI«v (Unholy Nexus) Fs¶ms¡ ]dbpsa¦nepw Ah AhnlnX Imcy§Ä \S¯p¶ Xnepw \S¡pt¼mgpw am{Xta {]kàamIq Fs¶mcp hmZKXnbpw \ne\nev¡p¶p. \nbaw \nba¯nsâ hgn¡v apt¶dpsa¶v ]ecpw ]dbp¶ps­¦nepw ]dbp¶hscÃmw De facto C^Iväpw Cw]mIväpw [Effect and Impact] CÃmbva sN¿p¶pt­m F¶pIqsS ]cntim[nt¡ ­XmWv. De facto iàn {]hÀ¯n¡p¶ps­¦n \nbaw \nba¯nsâ hgn¡v t]mIpsa¶ {]kvXmh\IÄ Nne¡m¯ ssI¯mftam apg§m¯ tN§etbm BIpsa¶Xn XÀ¡w th­. s]mÅbmb “hÀ¯am\w” ]dbp¶Xnse´À°w?

“\nba\S]SnIÄ A«nadn¡s¸«p” F¶v ]et¸mgpw ]{X§fn {]Xy£s¸Smdp­v. A«nadn¡s¸Sm³ ZpÀ_eamtWm \nba hyhØbpw \nba\S]SnIfpw? iàcmb De facto iànIÄs¡Xnsc \nba§Äs¡´v {]kàn? kp\mansb¶ cm£k¯ncbpsS ap¼n Ns¯mSp§p¶ H¯ncn PohnIfps­t¶mÀ¡pI. A¯c¡msc Ipgn¨paqSpIsb¶Xp Xs¶ Akm[yamb ImcyamsW¶v ImWp¶hcmWv km[mcW¡mÀ. A¯cw F{Xtbmþ F{Xtbm kw`h§fmWv ImenI tIcf¯n \mw I­p sIm­ncn¡p¶Xv? a{´nk`m D]kanXnIÄ hsc ap«p aS¡p¶ De facto iàntI{µ§fp­v. s]meokhsc \njv{InbcmIp¶þ s]meokns\ hsc \njv{Inbcm¡p¶ De factoIÄ D­v. ]Whpw kzm[o\hpw aÊnepw iànbpw ssI¿neps­¦n \nba§Ä hgnamdns¡m Sp¡p¶ ZpchØ \ne\nev¡p¶p.

Hscmä cmjv{Sob I£n¡p am{Xw `qcn]£apsÅmcp a{´nk` cq]oIcn¡m³ Ignbm¯nSt¯mfw Imew ]e]e CuÀ¡nen ]mÀ«nIfpw De facto iànIfmbn amdnsb¶ncIpw. AhcpsS iàn {]IS\§Ä¡nSbn Aiàcmth­ ZpÀKXnbmWv De jure¡p­mhpI. Htc ]mÀ«nbnÂs¸« c­p hn`mK¡mÀ ]ckv]cw hg¡Sn¡pt¼mÄ AhcpsS CSbn Ignbp¶ De jurebpw AiàamIp¶p. `cWI£nbnÂs¸«hcpw {]Xn]£ I£nbn s¸«hcpw X½n¯½n t]mÀhnfn \S¯pt¼mÄ De jure sNIp¯m\pw \Sp¡Sen\pw at[y sNs¶¯p¶p. c­v aXhn`mK§Ä X½n X½ntem Hcp aX¯nÂs¸« c­p Iq«w A\pbmbnIÄ ]ckv]ctam FXncn«mepw De jure {Xni¦p kzÀ¤¯nemhp¶p. A§s\ t\m¡pt¼mÄ Ft¸mgpw De jure hnPbn¡psat¶m De facto ]cmPbs¸Spsat¶m ]dbpI h¿. c­n Hcp Iq«À hnPbn¡pw; hnPbw ]eXnt\bpw B{ibn¨ncn¡pw. c­pt]À¡pw \nba§Ä ewLn¡mw. ImcWw, c­pIq«cpw \nba¯n\p apIfn h«wId§p¶hcmWv. \nbaw F¶Xv De jure ]dbp¶XmsW¦nepw AXv De facto sN¿p¶Xp t]msebncn¡pw. AXpsIm­mWv ‘Show me the man, I shall tell you the law’ F¶p De jure ]dbp¶Xv.